Owner James Huffman says he can no longer sit and hope for a miracle.
"If things would get better, maybe you could, but things aren't getting better," said Huffman.
The last time he paid rent was back in March. Now they're behind over $30,000 and he understands the landlord can only wait so long.
Orange County orders all bars that don't offer dine-in services to shut down again
"When you're a small community theater that's a non-profit, there isn't a bundle of money sitting around. We're going month to month to month all the time," he said.
In Orange County, there are at least a dozen theaters like this that survive off of ticket sales and donations. If the shutdown continues through next spring, James believes as many as 70% of them will disappear, especially those not subsidized by a city.
"Everybody's nervous. I'm the first one I think to go ahead and close down only because I just think it's so clear, that I can't hang on," said Huffman.
Now he's busy sorting through everything, deciding what will go to storage, what will be sold at a rummage sale, and what will be donated.
"We have a ton of furniture, we have props, we have set pieces, we have 4,000 costumes," he said.
Although James helped build the physical theater from scratch, what he'll miss most are the people who came through its doors.
"The worst part is, theater is community. It's a cast being together, it's being together with your patrons," said Huffman.
The Attic Theater plans to be fully moved out by the end of the month. They'll fund raise in hopes of coming back at the end of all of this at a new location.