The game-ending double play sealed the Angels' 6-0 shutout, but Simmons took exception to Odor's attempt to break it up. Benches cleared and peace was quickly restored, but the accounts of the play were just beginning.
"He pushed me," Odor told reporters after the game. "I was surprised because I made a good slide. It was not a dirty slide. I tried to break up the double play with a good slide. That's why I was surprised he pushed me like that.
"He was angry, but I was like, 'What are you talking about?' I made a good slide. It was not dirty. [Ian] Kinsler was talking to me too, and he was fine. This is part of the game."
Simmons, a three-time Gold Glove winner, vehemently disagreed.
"When I get out of the way, I'm normally pretty good, so I don't have a problem normally," Simmons said when asked how often he gets spiked turning a double play.
Rangers manager Jeff Banister thought the slide was "appropriate," while Angels manager Mike Scioscia said he thought Odor took "a little bit of a veer ... a little bit wide" and spiked Simmons.
Simmons refused to elaborate further as to what happened on the play.
"Nothing," Simmons said while eating gelato. "I was trying to tell him, 'You forgot to say hello to your family for me.' He's like, 'No, I didn't forget, I told them.' I was like, 'No, they told me you didn't tell them.' He wasn't very happy about it, so it's OK.
"... I'm gonna eat my gelato and sleep well at night."
Scioscia and Simmons said the leg would be fine, and the shortstop isn't expected to miss any time.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Benches clear as Simmons takes exception to Odor's slide
Rougned Odor sticks out his leg to try and break up a game-ending double play, which angers Andrelton Simmons and empties both benches.