Hawes filed online on her grandmother's behalf.
"After several questions and putting in all the information it tells us that there is already a claim with that home address and with my information," Hawes said.
When she saw that message, Hawes thought it was a mistake - but it wasn't.
Hawes says after failing to get any help over the FEMA hotline she came to one of the FEMA pop-up locations.
She says a FEMA representative deleted the fake claim and helped them file a new one.
FEMA public affairs specialist Kim Kevlish says fraud unfortunately follows every disaster.
"We ask for social security number, we're able to verify that. We ask for documentation about home ownership or occupancy," Kevlish said when asked how FEMA verifies addresses when people file claims.
Hawes and her grandmother would like some federal help to fix their roof soon, so they're a little frustrated at FEMA right now - but they have even harsher words for the fraudster.
"I really hope that they're caught and stop what they're doing," Hawes' grandmother said.