Death toll in Metrolink crash rises to 25

Mayor Villaraigosa says the death toll from the Chatsworth crash coud still rise.
CHATSWORTH, Calif. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa asked local clergy to give a moment of silence for crash victims during Sunday services.

"Our number one priority remains rescuing victims caring for the injured and connecting with the families still missing their loved ones," the mayor said in a statement. "Today our thoughts and prayers of the people of Los Angeles are with the families who suffered loss last night and those still waiting for their loved ones to come home."

The Los Angeles County Coroner's office released a partial list of people killed in the crash.

  • Spree Desha, 35, of Simi Valley, Los Angeles Police Department Officer
  • Jacob Hefter, 18, of Palmdale, a student at California State University, Long Beach
  • Maria Elenea Villalobos, 18, of North Park, a student at the Fashion Institute of Design & Merchandising
  • Donna Remata, 49, of Simi Valley
  • Christopher Aiken, 38
  • Alan Lloyd Buckley, 59
  • Dennis Arnold, 75
  • Charles Peck, 58
  • Manuel Macias, 31
  • Yi Chao, 71
  • Walter Arney Fuller, 54
  • Atul Vyas, 20
  • Aida Magdeleno, 19
  • Howard Barry Pompel, 69
  • Ernest Stephen Kish II, 47
  • Dean Lafoy Brower, 51
  • Gregory Lintner, 48
  • Michael Hammersly, 45
  • Doyle Jay Souser, 56
  • Kari Hsieh, no age given
  • Families of two male victims and one female have not been notified and the coroner's office has not released their names. Two other men, one of whom died at a hospital, also have not been identified.


    - Get information on railway closures by visting the Metrolink Web site here.

    At the center of the investigation are continued questions and details surrounding the actions of the trains engineer.

    On Saturday Metrolink spokeswoman Denise Tyrree said the crash was caused by an error from the engineer. Tyrree said the engineer missed a signal light causing the metrolink train to crash head on with a freight train.

    The engineer, who has not been officially identified, was among the people killed in the crash.

    The search for survivors ended Saturday with 25 people confirmed dead and about 135 others injured. An LAPD officer was among those killed in the train crash.

    The commuter train and a Union Pacific freight train collided in Chatsworth Friday afternoon, trapping passengers inside at least three Metrolink cars, one of which caught fire.

    On Friday, September 12, 2008 at 4:23 PM, 38 Companies of Los Angeles Firefighters, 28 LAFD Rescue Ambulances, 1 Heavy Rescue, 1 Urban Search and Rescue Unit, 2 Rehab Units, 1 Hazardous Materials Team, 4 Helicopters, 7 EMS Battalion Captains, 8 Battalion Chief Officer Command Teams, 1 Division Chief Officer Command Team, Foam Tenders 100 & 60, Emergency Air 1, the Heavy Equipment Company, Emergency Lighting 72, 83 and 112, responded to reports of a train derailment at 21631 W. Heather Lee Ln. in the Chatsworth area.

    During the night, crews used hydraulic jacks to keep the passenger car from falling over and other specialized rescue equipment to gently tear apart the metal.

    Metrolink provided a telephone information line to provide answers specifically for family members. The number for family members: (800) 371-5465. The public was asked to keep the lines open for family members to call in.

    A public unification center was set up at Chatsworth High School, 10027 Lurline Ave., near Devonshire St. and De Soto Ave. The number for the unification center is (818) 678-3422. The public has been advised to keep the area clear for emergency personnel and family members.

    For information on local hospitals that might have knowledge of victims from the collision, please call (213) 847-8486.

    Both trains were derailed Friday afternoon. Seven freight cars derailed, and the locomotive and one passenger car of the Metrolink train were knocked over. The collision occurred at approximately 4:23 p.m. The National Transportation Safety Board will investigate the incident.

    The collision happened near Rinaldi Street, east of Topanga Canyon Boulevard and west of Canoga Avenue near Stoney Point Park, just south of the 118 Freeway near the Ventura County line. Firefighters set up a triage staging area at the park.

    L.A. City Fire Dept. Spokesperson d'Lisa Davies said the Coroner's Office confirmed 10 dead as of 9 p.m. Friday. Thirty to 35 injured patients had been airlifted to hospitals around the county. No children have been reported involved in the collision. It is estimated there may be as many as 100 people injured.

    Davies said heavy moving equipment was on its way to the scene of the collision in order to right the derailed Metrolink car to search for further victims in the train or underneath. Search dogs were also on the way to the scene to help in inaccessible areas.

    One firefighter was overcome with exhaustion earlier in the day, Davies said. That firefighter was transported to a hospital and was since recovering.

    An LAPD officer was confirmed killed in the crash. Officer Spree Desha was an LAPD officer for seven years.

    L.A. City Fire Department Chief Dennis Barry spoke at a news conference at 8:40 p.m. Barry reported that there was a hazardous-material situation from the crash from leaking fuel. Firefighters were able to gain control over the haz-mat situation and douse the burning cars.

    There were 250 firefighters on scene, said Barry. Civilians were among the firefighters and police that helped pull victims from the commuter train shortly after it crashed.

    Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa arrived on scene in the early evening for a briefing from incident officials. He spoke to reporters at the triage area in the park.

    Mayor Villaraigosa estimated there may be as many as 10 to 15 fatalities and 50 to 60 injuries, but those numbers were not confirmed, and the number was expected to rise.

    The L.A. Fire Dept. was running the unified command, according to the mayor.

    Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Baca confirmed that the County Sheriff's Dept. was "effectively working for the city" during the rescue efforts.

    Sheriff Baca said a uniformed deputy sheriff was onboard the train during the collision and sounded the alarm. That deputy reportedly suffered broken bones and a punctured lung.

    According to Metrolink Spokesperson Denise Tyrrell, Metrolink train #111 originated out of Union Station in L.A. It was estimated that 350 passengers were on the train. Metrolink train #111 normally travels to Moorpark in Ventura County.

    According to Tyrrell, the rest of the Metrolink train service is still operating with normal localized delays. Tyrrell stressed that the Metrolink emergency information line, (800) 371-5465, was for family members only.

    According to Union Pacific spokesperson Zoe Richmond, there are typically two crew members on each freight train voyage, the conductor and the engineer, both of whom occupy the lead locomotive engine. The spokesperson said the company had not yet been in contact with anyone from the stricken freight train.

    The locomotive car of the Metrolink train pulled (not pushed) the rest of the commuter train. The collision was severe enough to push the locomotive car into the passenger car behind it. Three passenger cars were attached to the locomotive. The passenger cars do not have seatbelts for riders.

    According to Tyrrell, Metrolink passenger cars weigh approximately 119 tons. The locomotive engines weigh approximately 450 tons.

    Tyrrell said there was no word yet from the conductor of the Metrolink train. Conductors are sub-contractors and do not work directly for Metrolink.

    The Union Pacific freight train had passed through a tunnel through the Santa Susana Pass that connects Simi Valley to Chatsworth. Metrolink Spokesperson Tyrrell said the tracks are used by Metrolink, Amtrak and freight trains.

    The Metrolink train's lead engine car could be seen on fire minutes after the crash. Firefighters doused the flames at the scene quickly.

    Firefighters could be seen breaking windows to reach and rescue passengers inside one Metrolink passenger car.

    A Sikorsky helicopter was at the scene Friday evening. The large helicopter is sometimes called a "floating hospital." An LAPD mobile sub-station arrived at approximately 6:40 p.m. Fire trucks were using Rinaldi St. as an access road to the crash.

    Medics arrived quickly on scene after the crash. Several victims could be seen being treated at the scene by emergency personnel immediately after the crash.

    At Stoney Point Park at the end of Heather Lee Lane, rescuers set up red, yellow and green and color-coded tarpaulins to distinguish the different injuries: Immediate (red), Delayed (yellow), and Minor (green). Helicopters were conducting airlifts from the parking lot of Stoney Point Park.

    A Valleywide Tactical Alert was called by authorities, which puts all LAPD officers in the region on active duty to tend to the emergency. The alert is standard procedure. The alert expired around 9:30 p.m.

    A huge crowd of firefighters could be seen swarming over passenger cars, extracting crash victims in an organized, orderly fashion.

    "L.A. County is the most organized when it comes to mutual assistance," said L.A. County Sheriff Lee Baca after arriving at the scene.

    UCLA Medical Center has pointed out the need for blood donation at this time. People can donate blood to UCLA Medical Center between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m. Saturday. For more information on donating blood, go to the UCLA Blood and Platelet Center

    In an unrelated accident, a Metrolink train collided with a car in Corona almost an hour after the Chatsworth crash. The driver of the car was killed and one passenger on that train was injured. The car was apparently attempting to cross the tracks. The crash happened on the 100 block of N. Sheridan St. in Corona, according to the Corona Fire Dept.


    - Get more local news headlines from Los Angeles
    - Have a news tip? Send your tips, video, or pictures

    Copyright © 2022 KABC Television, LLC. All rights reserved.