Bay Area man loses all his unemployment benefits after returning EDD overpayment

SAN ANSELMO, Calif. -- A Bay Area man tried to do the right thing when the Employment Development Department accidentally overpaid his benefits. His efforts to return the money set off a chain of unfortunate events that he's still trying to unwind months later.

The construction worker now regrets even applying for unemployment. All Mathew Lombardi can do is laugh about his problem.

Like so many others, he lost his job as a construction supervisor of a San Francisco project back in March.

It was the first time he has ever been out of work. He wasn't sure if the trouble of filing for benefits would be worth it.

"But when the federal government chipped in that extra $600 per week, I felt it was beneficial," he said.

RELATED: Third stimulus check updates: Senate nears votes on $1.9T COVID relief bill
EMBED More News Videos

The Senate is steering toward a voting marathon on Democrats' $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief bill.



Lombardi applied, but the backlog of applications meant a delay in receiving his first check. By that time, his construction project had resumed after a seven-week layoff.

He ended up receiving an extra $2,100 in benefits. He reported the overpayment to the state.

That money would be later subtracted from his debit card -- and more.

"I had gone back to check the balance and it was zero," Lombardi recalled.

The state not only took his extra $2,100 but another $1,600 on top of that, totally draining his account.

He called Bank of America, which told both him and KGO-TV's 7 On Your Side that EDD handles resolving overpayments.

He's also tried contacting EDD but was unsuccessful.

RELATED: LA man waiting months for unemployment aid says EDD put him on hold for 9 hours
EMBED More News Videos

A Los Angeles resident has made calling the EDD a daily routine as he tries to get updates on his pending claim. One day, he says he got through, only to be put on hold for nine hours.



To make matters worse, Lombardi has now received a tax bill which included not only the overpayment but the money that was his but had been taken away.

"This has gone from being an EDD issue to potentially an IRS problem that I might have down the road," he said.

The IRS is advising him to ask the EDD for a revised 1099. If he's unsuccessful, he should pay taxes only on the income he really earned.

Raphael Tulino of the IRS says that should be the end of it.

"I'm not guaranteeing anything. The IRS doesn't guarantee anything. But what I'm saying is, file a federal tax return that accurately reflects your situation," Tulino said.

CPA Jim McHale thinks Matthew should take it one step further.

"There's an identity theft form for the IRS. You file that and you say, 'I believe I've been a victim of identity theft,'" McHale said.

The IRS says that's not necessary.

Lombardi says he's just tired.

"Now I've spent numerous hours trying to unwind this story and I guess it became more aggravating," he said.

The EDD has answers to frequently asked questions about 1099 forms on its website.

RELATED: Fraud overwhelms pandemic-related unemployment programs
EMBED More News Videos

A man in Chicago was surprised to receive an unemployment tax form from the state of Ohio. That's because he's never lived in Ohio and he hasn't filed for unemployment.

Copyright © 2021 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.