Newsom withholds COVID money from 2 defiant cities that allow businesses to reopen amid pandemic

The city councils in both cities met Monday and stuck with their resolutions.

AP logo
Wednesday, July 29, 2020
State withholds funding from Atwater, Coalinga for defying public health orders
Coalinga and Atwater have received notices that they won't get emergency state funding.

SACRAMENTO, Calif. -- Gov. Gavin Newsom is using new powers to withhold money from two cities in California's Central Valley that are defying his health orders by allowing all businesses to open during the pandemic.

Newsom blocked nearly $65,000 from Atwater in Merced County and more than $35,000 from Coalinga in Fresno County, the first installments of $2.5 billion in federal funds that cities and counties across the state risk losing if they don't toe the line on coronavirus safeguards.

The state's Office of Emergency Services sent letters to the cities last week notifying officials that they risked losing more money if they didn't withdraw resolutions defying the state's orders. The city councils in both cities met Monday and stuck with their resolutions.

MORE: These California cities will fine you for not wearing a mask or face covering

"We chose our path and we prepared for it." Atwater Mayor Paul Creighton said.

Creighton said the governor is abandoning the small city even as he devotes more resources and federal money to combat a virus surge in the Central Valley. Creighton said sentiment in his city of 29,000 seems to be running about 80-20 in defiance of the governor.

WATCH: Here's a breakdown of Gov. Gavin Newsom's four stage plan to reopen California amid COVID-19

We've broken down Gov. Gavin Newsom's 4 phase plan with what's reopening in California.

Newsom was granted the power to block the money in the new state budget that took effect earlier this month. The cities lost the first one-sixth of their money but can get the rest if they rescind their resolutions, Office of Emergency Services spokesman Brian Ferguson said.

Atwater is eligible for $389,000 and Coalinga for $216,000 in assistance through the state's Coronavirus Relief Fund.

On Monday, Newsom announced he would spend $52 million in the Central Valley to improve virus testing and provide other help to residents in the agricultural region that has a high population of Hispanics, a group disproportionately harmed by the virus. The state also is sending strike teams of health care workers to help hospitals handle the additional cases.

California Health and Human Services Secretary Dr. Mark Ghaly said Tuesday the rate of hospitalizations statewide is slowing and in some parts even flattening.

"We don't see that in the Central Valley," he said.

Merced County on Monday reported its highest-ever number of virus hospitalizations, while Fresno County is just below its highest level. Health officials in the two counties did not respond to telephone and email requests for comment on the cities' defiance.

Virus cases in California started surging in early June and in early July Newsom reimposed shutdown orders on many businesses while also barring indoor religious services and in-school instruction for students in most of the state.

WATCH: Gov. Gavin Newsom announces new guidelines for hair salons and other beauty services to operate outside amid COVID-19

Gov. Gavin Newsom announced a change in the rules for hair salons and other beauty services in a Monday press conference on the coronavirus pandemic.

Atwater's City Council declared itself a "Sanctuary City" for businesses and made it clear it won't enforce the state's public health order. Coalinga's City Council approved a resolution calling all businesses "essential" and thus able to remain open despite the state's shutdown orders.

"It's just politics, that we have the word 'sanctuary' for businesses and faith-based (organizations)," Creighton said, adding that, "We support 'open and safe' - masks, social distancing."

The money from the state fund would have gone to help local businesses hard hit during the pandemic, to buy more personal protective equipment, and to more education and outreach, he said.

"Everything we need that money to do, we're not going to be able to do now," Creighton said.

City officials would like to sue the state, he said, but can't afford to fight that battle.

For the latest updates and resources on the coronavirus, visit